Use Of 3Rd Political Party Cookies Is Non The Problem
Tuesday, October 15, 2019
Edit
The contestation over "third party" cookies, too filtering, continues daily.
Today, a weblog possessor suggests that solving the occupation of inability to comment, past times "requiring" each reader to un filter "third party" cookies, is unacceptable - because each reader has to bring action, to solve the problem.
Another weblog owner, quest why Blogger won't ignore his pageviews when visiting his blog, takes exclusively a pair hours to read too to diagnose the problem, too thence dismisses the advice
Both weblog owners are ignoring the actual problem.
Blogger did non practise a requirement called "third political party cookies". Blogger, similar Google, too similar nearly Internet services, role cookies to retain information, from each of us, equally nosotros role Blogger.
When you lot role your favourite website approximately time, for to a greater extent than than precisely viewing, expect at what you lot are doing.
When you lot role Blogger, you lot hold upwards into information on ane screen, too role it from another.
You hold upwards into information - possibly login, possibly compose a post - on ane screen. You press "Enter" ("Publish", what conduct hold you), too you lot run across approximately other screen.
How does the information larn read on ane screen, too thence displayed, on approximately other screen? You're using HTTP (HTTPS, what conduct hold you), to communicate amongst the server - too HTTP et al is a connectionless protocol. Nothing is stored on the server (so many servers, worldwide), to position you lot from concealment to screen.
There are 2 ways to position you, from concealment to screen.
There are 2 ways of identifying you, from concealment to screen.
Take a expect at the latter solution, first. I'm editing this post - too hither is the URL that's used, past times the post editor.
But in that place is secure content, that exclusively I tin role (through my browser) - that is someone to me. That content is stored on my computer, equally tiny encrypted files, called "cookies". Why such a cute name, for such a serious detail?
Private details - such equally my occupation organisation human relationship advert / electronic mail address, when I logged inwards to Blogger, possibly my IP address or hardware address - are stored inwards cookies.
Look at the URLs, inwards the address windows, when you lot role Blogger.
I login to Google, using a display that runs from "google.com". The side past times side fourth dimension you lot login, expect at the address inwards the browser window. You'll likely run across the same.
I role the Blogger dashboard from "blogger.com". You'll practise the same, when you lot hold too unwrap your blog.
I sentiment this blog, equally "blogging.nitecruzr.net". Since you lot are reading this, you lot are doing the same. five years ago, you lot powerfulness conduct hold viewed this weblog equally "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.com" (from many countries, such equally USA).
Outside the USA, you lot may conduct hold viewed this weblog equally "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.co.uk" (in the UK), "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.fr" (in France), "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.th" (in Thailand) - or whatsoever of several dozen other unlike countries worldwide, each amongst a complemntary alias.
Where am I going amongst this?
These are all unlike domains. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 cookie, created nether whatsoever ane domain, too read nether approximately other domain, is called a 3rd political party cookie.
You conduct hold to trust Blogger too Google, to role their services effectively.
If you lot are going to role Blogger, you lot conduct hold to trust Blogger, too Google. That includes trusting any Google domain - too allow them to practise too read cookies, betwixt domains.
And allowing Google to practise too read cookies, between domains, requires that you lot - and your readers - allow 3rd political party cookies. This is non the same equally clearing cookies.
All of these activities - too to a greater extent than - require that the Blogger script, that you lot (your reader) run, reads a cookie created inwards approximately other domain. That is a third political party cookie.
Third political party cookies are non a devious plot, to violate your privacy.
Third political party cookies are non an evil plot, past times Google - nor should they require disclosure, inwards a formal banner. Even though they do, inwards Europe.
Third political party cookies are only a means of letting you lot role the many Google services - without endangering your security, past times retaining massive amounts of session content inwards the URL, equally you lot role multiple displays. When you lot (or a reader) conduct hold a occupation using or viewing your weblog (or Blogger), ane of the simplest things to practise is to check / right cookie filters.
Today, a weblog possessor suggests that solving the occupation of inability to comment, past times "requiring" each reader to un filter "third party" cookies, is unacceptable - because each reader has to bring action, to solve the problem.
Another weblog owner, quest why Blogger won't ignore his pageviews when visiting his blog, takes exclusively a pair hours to read too to diagnose the problem, too thence dismisses the advice
That didn't actually help.
Both weblog owners are ignoring the actual problem.
Blogger did non practise a requirement called "third political party cookies". Blogger, similar Google, too similar nearly Internet services, role cookies to retain information, from each of us, equally nosotros role Blogger.
When you lot role your favourite website approximately time, for to a greater extent than than precisely viewing, expect at what you lot are doing.
When you lot role Blogger, you lot hold upwards into information on ane screen, too role it from another.
You hold upwards into information - possibly login, possibly compose a post - on ane screen. You press "Enter" ("Publish", what conduct hold you), too you lot run across approximately other screen.
How does the information larn read on ane screen, too thence displayed, on approximately other screen? You're using HTTP (HTTPS, what conduct hold you), to communicate amongst the server - too HTTP et al is a connectionless protocol. Nothing is stored on the server (so many servers, worldwide), to position you lot from concealment to screen.
There are 2 ways to position you, from concealment to screen.
There are 2 ways of identifying you, from concealment to screen.
- Cookie.
- URL inwards stream values.
Take a expect at the latter solution, first. I'm editing this post - too hither is the URL that's used, past times the post editor.
What you lot run across in that place is what is passed, from ane concealment to another. It tells what I'm doing ("blogger.g"), what weblog ("24069595") too post ("7677866552420604366") I'm working on, too what context I'm inwards ("allposts" , or " · Posts › All"). All of this is populace details, I don't hear showing this much.https://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=24069595#editor/target=post;postID=7677866552420604366;onPublishedMenu=allposts;onClosedMenu=allposts;postNum=0;src=link
But in that place is secure content, that exclusively I tin role (through my browser) - that is someone to me. That content is stored on my computer, equally tiny encrypted files, called "cookies". Why such a cute name, for such a serious detail?
Private details - such equally my occupation organisation human relationship advert / electronic mail address, when I logged inwards to Blogger, possibly my IP address or hardware address - are stored inwards cookies.
Look at the URLs, inwards the address windows, when you lot role Blogger.
I login to Google, using a display that runs from "google.com". The side past times side fourth dimension you lot login, expect at the address inwards the browser window. You'll likely run across the same.
I role the Blogger dashboard from "blogger.com". You'll practise the same, when you lot hold too unwrap your blog.
I sentiment this blog, equally "blogging.nitecruzr.net". Since you lot are reading this, you lot are doing the same. five years ago, you lot powerfulness conduct hold viewed this weblog equally "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.com" (from many countries, such equally USA).
Outside the USA, you lot may conduct hold viewed this weblog equally "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.co.uk" (in the UK), "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.fr" (in France), "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.th" (in Thailand) - or whatsoever of several dozen other unlike countries worldwide, each amongst a complemntary alias.
Where am I going amongst this?
- "google.com"
- "blogger.com"
- "blogging.nitecruzr.net"
- "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.com"
- "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.co.uk"
- "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.fr"
- "bloggerstatusforreal.blogspot.th"
These are all unlike domains. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 cookie, created nether whatsoever ane domain, too read nether approximately other domain, is called a 3rd political party cookie.
You conduct hold to trust Blogger too Google, to role their services effectively.
If you lot are going to role Blogger, you lot conduct hold to trust Blogger, too Google. That includes trusting any Google domain - too allow them to practise too read cookies, betwixt domains.
And allowing Google to practise too read cookies, between domains, requires that you lot - and your readers - allow 3rd political party cookies. This is non the same equally clearing cookies.
- Login to Google.
- Access your favourite blog, behind a Content Warning.
- Post a comment, on your favourite blog.
- View your blog, without having Stats count your visits.
- Edit a post, inwards your blog.
- Preview a post, inwards your blog
- Preview the template, inwards your blog.
All of these activities - too to a greater extent than - require that the Blogger script, that you lot (your reader) run, reads a cookie created inwards approximately other domain. That is a third political party cookie.
Third political party cookies are non a devious plot, to violate your privacy.
Third political party cookies are non an evil plot, past times Google - nor should they require disclosure, inwards a formal banner. Even though they do, inwards Europe.
Third political party cookies are only a means of letting you lot role the many Google services - without endangering your security, past times retaining massive amounts of session content inwards the URL, equally you lot role multiple displays. When you lot (or a reader) conduct hold a occupation using or viewing your weblog (or Blogger), ane of the simplest things to practise is to check / right cookie filters.